
The chorus was rattling around in my head for some time. I imagined a very Love Jones-style production on this- lots of harmonies. Still, it's part of the same batch, and I wasn't so sure that it would work as a solo acoustic song. Some songs rattle around for a while, and the key to getting the song started is all about the first line sometimes.
The ghosts, the graves, the ghouls are going by you
And they glide right by your gaze.
Once I had that, I was off to the races. It was clear that alliteration was going to be a big part. That's kind of the key to songwriting. Before you set out to write a song, there are a myriad of possibilities, but once you have your first line, choices are made, and boundaries go up. Sometimes the boundaries prevent you from moving forward, which is a sure sign that the first line isn't right, but if that's not the case, there is a logical progression as the song presents itself to you. I've always said that I'm less of a songwriter, and more of a song-diviner, or maybe song-deliverer.
The song seems to have two different pronoun perspectives. The verses are all in second person. This can make it seem very accusatory. Then the chorus is in the first-person plural. If you're doing the big soup-to-nuts production, that's easy to illustrate. One voice in the verse and another set of voices in the chorus representing the clueless. When you have one voice doing the whole thing, it changes the song a bit.
I've taught song studies many times over the course of my teaching career. If I ask students what a song is, they will usually reply: words and music. The performance is often left out of the equation, but the performance is part of the equation. When I first heard Tom Petty singing “Change the Locks”, I heard the song as being about a guy who was in a bad relationship and was happy to be out of it. When I heard Lucinda William's version of the same song, I got a very different reading of it. I began to wonder if the woman in the song is trying to steer clear of an abusive man. Still the same song, but the performance matters.
When you have the same voice throughout this song, I think it implies that, while at first glance, it might appear that it's those people who are the problem, there is an acknowledgement that maybe we are the problem. It softens the song a bit, and makes it less theatrical. Still, I wonder if the Love Jones need a song for their next album?
The first pass I did of this at Downtown Recording Studios occurred early in the session. I was very amped, and as a result, I sang the third verse an octave higher, and not in falsetto. It kind of overpowered the song, so we did another take where I stayed in the same range throughout. I have quite a range. Somehow, I've managed to keep a lot of my high notes, but as I've gotten older, I'm a lot more confident with my low notes. I often feel like I'm still learning how to sing. Some of that is the result of our voice changing over the years.
